Skip to main content

M1 Pro Soft Short — PP3V3_S2 Resistive Leakage

M1 Pro Soft Short — PP3V3_S2 Resistive Leakage

Status: repaired successfully · Channel: Paul Daniels · Published: 2024-10-26 · Runtime: 31:40 Model: MacBook Pro 16" M1 Pro (A2485) · Board: 820-02100 Source: YouTube Fault class: Resistive semiconductor leakage ("soft short") on a secondary standby rail

Summary

A static 5 V / 180 mA draw with no boot. Diode mode on PP3V3_S2 read 0.082 V (healthy reference > 0.400 V); resistance ~120 Ω. Because a 50–200 Ω leak trips no short-killer and gets barely warm, location was done by controlled injection: 1.2 V at 1.5 A onto the rail with a thermal imager, which showed a ~3.5 °C rise on a peripheral IC. Removing that IC restored the rail to 0.435 V and the board negotiated 20 V.

Timeline

Time Evidence Observation
03:15 [measured] USB-C meter: 5.15 V, continuous static 0.18 A (180 mA).
09:40 [measured] Diode mode PP3V3_S2 = 0.082 V to ground (ref > 0.400 V); resistance ~120 Ω.
16:20 [stated] Paul: a "soft short" (50–200 Ω) will not trip short-killers and does not get scorching hot, making it far harder to locate than a dead short.
22:30 [measured] Inject 1.2 V (1.5 A limit) onto PP3V3_S2; thermal imager shows a subtle ~3.5 °C rise on a peripheral logic IC.
27:10 [measured] Leaking IC desoldered; diode mode returns to 0.435 V; board negotiates 20 V.

Measurements

Time Measurement Value Context
03:15 Voltage / current 5.15 V / 0.18 A Static draw
09:40 Diode mode 0.082 V PP3V3_S2 to ground
09:42 Resistance 121.4 Ω PP3V3_S2 to ground
27:10 Diode mode 0.435 V After repair

Diagnostic reasoning

  • Observation — static 180 mA at 5 V; PP3V3_S2 shows ~120 Ω instead of high impedance.
  • Stated mechanism — the fault is internal semiconductor junction degradation, not a cracked ceramic capacitor.
  • Inference — a rail loaded to 120 Ω cannot hold 3.3 V, so the PMIC power-good flag stays low and blocks 20 V negotiation.
  • Resolution — thermal imaging under controlled 1.2 V injection located the leaking IC; removing it restored normal rail impedance.

Repair procedure

  1. Run a diode-mode audit to isolate the leaking rail.
  2. Connect a bench supply at 1.2 V (not full rail voltage) to avoid damaging silicon.
  3. Watch the thermal signature under high-gain thermal imaging.
  4. Desolder the leaking IC with hot air.
  5. Re-verify the rail diode value and boot the board.

Claims audit

ID Claim Evidence Note
C1 Soft shorts pull down PMIC power-good signals, locking the machine at 5 V without tripping overcurrent shutdown. [inferred] The behavioural claim is well demonstrated; the internal power-good mechanism is inferred.
C2 Low-voltage (1.2 V) injection is the safe way to find such leaks. [stated] Sound practice; keep the current limit low and the voltage below the rail's nominal.
  • [[m3-spmu]] — a 5 V / 50 mA stall from an entirely different cause.
  • [[dfu-inductor]] — rail integrity issues that only appear under dynamic load.

Provenance: condensed from the video's audio transcript (Google AI Studio); timestamps, refdes and values are as stated in the video and are not independently verified.