Skip to main content

M1 Pro No Charge — Open SMBus SCL Trace

M1 Pro No Charge — Open SMBus SCL Trace

Status: repaired successfully · Channel: Paul Daniels · Published: 2024-11-01 · Runtime: 24:18 Model: MacBook Pro 16" M1 Pro (A2485) · Board: 820-02100 Source: YouTube Fault class: Open-circuit battery I2C clock line

Summary

After a customer's own battery replacement the machine would not charge. On the charger it drew only 5 V / 0.02 A. Diode mode on SMBUS_BATT_SCL read OL at the connector. Under the microscope, the trace from series resistor R5151 to J5150 was severed by a screwdriver slip. A 0.05 mm enamel jumper bridged the gap, restoring clock continuity and the charging state machine.

Timeline

Time Evidence Observation
03:40 [measured] New battery fitted by customer; runs on charger but draws 5 V / 0.02 A with the battery alone, and will not charge.
08:15 [measured] Diode mode on SMBUS_BATT_SCL = OL at the battery connector pins.
14:20 [measured] Microscope: trace from R5151 to J5150 severed by a tool slip.
18:30 [measured] Trace scraped, bridged with 0.05 mm jumper wire, sealed with UV solder mask.
22:15 [measured] Diode mode on SCL restored to 0.540 V; board negotiates 20 V / 3.4 A and charges.

Measurements

Time Measurement Value Context
08:15 Diode mode OL SMBUS_BATT_SCL at connector pin
14:20 Resistance OL Across the severed trace gap
22:15 Diode mode 0.540 V SCL after jumper
22:40 Voltage / current 20.0 V / 3.42 A Charging

Diagnostic reasoning

  • Observation — a customer battery swap left a No Charge condition; SCL is completely open.
  • Stated mechanism — tool slips during battery removal frequently sever micro-traces running parallel to the board edge near J5150.
  • Resolution — bridging the severed trace with an enamel jumper restores clock continuity, letting the BMS and charger re-establish communication.

Repair procedure

  1. Trace battery-connector pins in diode mode to find broken signal lines.
  2. Identify the severed copper trace under a stereomicroscope.
  3. Scrape enamel mask from both sides of the fracture.
  4. Solder a 0.05 mm jumper wire across the gap.
  5. Insulate with UV-curable green solder mask.
  6. Verify charging and power operation.

Claims audit

ID Claim Evidence Note
C1 An open SCL halts the charger state machine, preventing any charging-current negotiation. [measured] Directly demonstrated. Note this is the opposite electrical fault (open) to the clamped-SDA case, with the same symptom.

Provenance: condensed from the video's audio transcript (Google AI Studio); timestamps, refdes and values are as stated in the video and are not independently verified.