M1 Max No Charge — Shorted SMBus TVS Diode
M1 Max No Charge — Shorted SMBus TVS Diode
Status: repaired successfully · Channel: Paul Daniels · Published: 2024-11-12 · Runtime: 16:22 Model: MacBook Pro 16" M1 Max (A2485) · Board: 820-02100 Source: YouTube Fault class: Battery communication bus clamped by a failed ESD diode
Summary
The machine ran normally on the adapter, but the battery menu showed an "X" —
Not Charging. On the battery communication bus SCL measured a healthy 3.29 V
while SDA was clamped to 0.20 V. A cracked, discoloured TVS ESD diode array next
to the battery connector J5150 had failed as a low-resistance path to ground,
holding the data line below the logic-high threshold. Removing it restored 3.30 V
and full charging.
Timeline
| Time | Evidence | Observation |
|---|---|---|
| 02:10 | [measured] |
Runs from USB-C adapter; battery menu shows "X", status Not Charging. |
| 05:30 | [measured] |
SMBUS_BATT_SCL = 3.29 V, but SMBUS_BATT_SDA clamped to 0.20 V. |
| 08:45 | [measured] |
Microscope: cracked, discoloured TVS ESD diode array adjacent to J5150. |
| 11:20 | [stated] |
Paul: the ESD diode took a surge and failed as a low-resistance path to ground, preventing the BMS from transmitting battery telemetry. |
| 12:10 | [measured] |
TVS array desoldered; SDA immediately recovers to 3.30 V. |
| 14:20 | [measured] |
With the battery connected, charging begins at 20.2 V / 4.20 A. |
Measurements
| Time | Measurement | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| 05:30 | Voltage | 0.20 V | SMBUS_BATT_SDA to ground (clamped) |
| 05:32 | Voltage | 3.29 V | SMBUS_BATT_SCL to ground (healthy) |
| 12:10 | Voltage | 3.30 V | SDA after diode removal |
| 14:20 | Voltage / current | 20.2 V / 4.20 A | Fast charging active |
Diagnostic reasoning
- Observation — boots on AC, battery unrecognised,
SDAclamped near 0 V. - Stated mechanism — the charger IC requires bidirectional SMBus with the BMS before enabling the charge MOSFETs.
- Inference — the shorted suppression diode clamps the data line below the logic-high threshold (0.2 V < ~2.0 V), so BMS telemetry never arrives.
- Resolution — removing the TVS diode restores the 3.3 V bus level, enabling BMS communication and full charging.
Repair procedure
- Probe the SMBus lines under AC power.
- Locate the damaged TVS ESD diode package near
J5150. - Desolder it with hot air (~350 °C).
- Fit a replacement TVS array from a donor 820-02100 board.
- Verify battery health and cycle count in System Information.
Claims audit
| ID | Claim | Evidence | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Clamping SDA to ground halts charging on M1 Max even though PPBUS_AON and VBUS are healthy. |
[measured] |
Directly demonstrated; a clean illustration that "charges on AC but no battery" is a bus fault, not a power-path fault. |
Related cases
[[m1pro-scl-open]]M1 Pro No Charge — Open SMBus SCL Trace — the open-circuit counterpart on the sameJ5150area.[[m2air-pullup]]M2 Air Battery Not Detected — Sheared SMBus Pull-Up — a sheared pull-up producing the same "no battery" symptom.
Provenance: condensed from the video's audio transcript (Google AI Studio); timestamps, refdes and values are as stated in the video and are not independently verified.