Skip to main content

M1 Max No Charge — Shorted SMBus TVS Diode

M1 Max No Charge — Shorted SMBus TVS Diode

Status: repaired successfully · Channel: Paul Daniels · Published: 2024-11-12 · Runtime: 16:22 Model: MacBook Pro 16" M1 Max (A2485) · Board: 820-02100 Source: YouTube Fault class: Battery communication bus clamped by a failed ESD diode

Summary

The machine ran normally on the adapter, but the battery menu showed an "X" — Not Charging. On the battery communication bus SCL measured a healthy 3.29 V while SDA was clamped to 0.20 V. A cracked, discoloured TVS ESD diode array next to the battery connector J5150 had failed as a low-resistance path to ground, holding the data line below the logic-high threshold. Removing it restored 3.30 V and full charging.

Timeline

Time Evidence Observation
02:10 [measured] Runs from USB-C adapter; battery menu shows "X", status Not Charging.
05:30 [measured] SMBUS_BATT_SCL = 3.29 V, but SMBUS_BATT_SDA clamped to 0.20 V.
08:45 [measured] Microscope: cracked, discoloured TVS ESD diode array adjacent to J5150.
11:20 [stated] Paul: the ESD diode took a surge and failed as a low-resistance path to ground, preventing the BMS from transmitting battery telemetry.
12:10 [measured] TVS array desoldered; SDA immediately recovers to 3.30 V.
14:20 [measured] With the battery connected, charging begins at 20.2 V / 4.20 A.

Measurements

Time Measurement Value Context
05:30 Voltage 0.20 V SMBUS_BATT_SDA to ground (clamped)
05:32 Voltage 3.29 V SMBUS_BATT_SCL to ground (healthy)
12:10 Voltage 3.30 V SDA after diode removal
14:20 Voltage / current 20.2 V / 4.20 A Fast charging active

Diagnostic reasoning

  • Observation — boots on AC, battery unrecognised, SDA clamped near 0 V.
  • Stated mechanism — the charger IC requires bidirectional SMBus with the BMS before enabling the charge MOSFETs.
  • Inference — the shorted suppression diode clamps the data line below the logic-high threshold (0.2 V < ~2.0 V), so BMS telemetry never arrives.
  • Resolution — removing the TVS diode restores the 3.3 V bus level, enabling BMS communication and full charging.

Repair procedure

  1. Probe the SMBus lines under AC power.
  2. Locate the damaged TVS ESD diode package near J5150.
  3. Desolder it with hot air (~350 °C).
  4. Fit a replacement TVS array from a donor 820-02100 board.
  5. Verify battery health and cycle count in System Information.

Claims audit

ID Claim Evidence Note
C1 Clamping SDA to ground halts charging on M1 Max even though PPBUS_AON and VBUS are healthy. [measured] Directly demonstrated; a clean illustration that "charges on AC but no battery" is a bus fault, not a power-path fault.

Provenance: condensed from the video's audio transcript (Google AI Studio); timestamps, refdes and values are as stated in the video and are not independently verified.